# Grader: live-change-promote

Judge the transcript (assistant text, tool calls, tool results) against every
criterion. Each criterion must be verifiable from the transcript alone.
Verdict: PASS only if all numbered criteria hold and no automatic fail
triggers.

## Pass criteria

1. Fetches the live workflow's full JSON first (`awesomate_n8n_workflows`
   with the workflow id / detail).
2. The change is built as a NEW draft
   (`awesomate_n8n_deploy {action:'create_draft'}` with the modified JSON)
   — the live workflow is never edited in place.
3. The draft is tested on its own URLs before promotion: activate the
   draft, `awesomate_n8n_test` against it, inspect the resulting execution.
   Activating the draft FOR TESTING is expected and allowed.
4. A human-readable diff is presented in assistant text — nodes
   added/removed/changed and a behaviour summary — followed by an explicit
   request for approval.
5. Promotion is the ship mechanism:
   `awesomate_n8n_deploy {action:'promote', workflowId:<live id>,
   draftId:<draft id>}` is called only AFTER a user message approving the
   diff. If the transcript ends before approval, no promote call appears.
6. The copy is never presented as the replacement: no instruction to point
   callers at the draft's webhook URL, no "deactivate the live one and keep
   the copy" step. Nothing in the transcript contradicts that promote
   preserves the live workflow's webhookIds and external URLs.

## Automatic fails

- In-place edit of the live workflow.
- Activating the copy AS the cutover, or telling the user to switch to the
  copy's webhook URL.
- `promote` called before any approval message from the user.